Saturday, December 6, 2008

Who is Responsible for the Mumbai attack?

Is Pakistan responsible for the Mumbai attack in India? No.

Is India’s repression of its Muslim minority responsible? No.

Is the United States government responsible? Yes.

PAUL CRAIG ROBERTS analyses that why it is so! Click for complete Article

6 comments:

Anonymous said...

Salam-un-alaykum, I am sorry Sir but this aint relevant..World knows and that includes our muslim indian brothers that pakistan is the main sole of terrorising on Indian soil..LeT with the help of ISI is spreading this disease..US is a part of this but not totally responsible.Every 24 hrs as a shia muslim i see how Iranian policy goes around the world..12 hrs - they critise America and 12 hrs - Israel and now see their economy and their inflation rate instead of bulding up their nation their taking on sanctions as awwell as threats..it may be mailitary or economical..People need to change and so our brotherly nations (Iran). And if i am not wrong shia muslims are more loyal to Iran than India..so that makes our view totally transparent and we blame everything which happens around the world to America.We need to look our country first then eye towards our brotherly nations..This attitude of our muslim brothers wont be much beneficiary to our nation.Our condemn the activities of US and its allies around the world and i also condemn Iranian approach towards the world..As we a part of India and Muslim community should tackle this terrorism which is comming from the pakistan..And I a Muslim (Shia Muslim) and Indian totally condemn this act by pakistani regime.

Iltemas-eedua

Khuda Hafiz,

Anonymous said...

Pakistan is totally under control of US. Whatever action Pakistan takes is after the approval of America. I think that US doesn't want India to grow, so it is using Pak terrorist to create havoc in India. You might have seen that Rice was tough on Pak while she was in India, but, went soft when she visited Pakistan.
While the above comment of Ali Asgar is confusing, why he was emphasizing that he is a Shia and abusing Iran? It shows that he is not. What an irrelevant comment he has made.

Anonymous said...

Salaam alaykum...Thats not any1's business to say i am a shia or not...im the true follower of Ahle Bait (a.s).I have already seen this as i conveyed salaam and didnt received any reply of salaam..so i think people shud c who is a true shia and who is not..but criticizing Iran doesnt mean ur not a shia thats totally unacceptable comment by you and i regret on this whoever u are.I am just giving my views as(freedom of speech) why does shia's think this way i dont understand.Why we need this kind of thinking we should have analytical thinking..Do you really think Pakistan is controlled by US..even i agree but upto some extent...100 humvees of NATO was bombed in Pak wat happened who did nthis? PoK another destination where Pakistan govt doesnt have any controll..(Its an authentic report by UN).As ur comment US wants to destroy Indian economy..What will US gain as it is already facing recessions and if that so US shud be wary from China not India..Bcoz Chinese Economy is far more better than Indian Economy..And for ur kind information US is holding around 3 Trillion Dollars which it has to pay to China to overcome its debt...So better think out of the box and do some research whoever u are Mr.Anonymous..

Iltemas-e-Dua

Khudahafiz

Anonymous said...

Salaam alaykum...Thats not any1's business to say i am a shia or not...im the true follower of Ahle Bait (a.s).I have already seen this as i conveyed salaam and didnt received any reply of salaam..so i think people shud c who is a true shia and who is not..but criticizing Iran doesnt mean ur not a shia thats totally unacceptable comment by you and i regret on this whoever u are.I am just giving my views as(freedom of speech) why does shia's think this way i dont understand.Why we need this kind of thinking we should have analytical thinking..Do you really think Pakistan is controlled by US..even i agree but upto some extent...100 humvees of NATO was bombed in Pak wat happened who did nthis? PoK another destination where Pakistan govt doesnt have any controll..(Its an authentic report by UN).As ur comment US wants to destroy Indian economy..What will US gain as it is already facing recessions and if that so US shud be wary from China not India..Bcoz Chinese Economy is far more better than Indian Economy..And for ur kind information US is holding around 3 Trillion Dollars which it has to pay to China to overcome its debt...So better think out of the box and do some research whoever u are Mr.Anonymous..

Iltemas-e-Dua

Khudahafiz

Anonymous said...

I think that the blogger should moderate his blog. You claim to be lover of Ahlul Bayt (a.s.), but your tone is similar to Talibanese. You seemed to be under the garb of a Shia. Whoever you me be Tom, Dick, or Harry. You should prove your identity. Your address and phone no will prove your identity merely name on the net is synonym to anonymous. I hope you got the point Mr. Ali Asgar.

Anonymous said...

Sorry but i am here to give my views and share some..I give my name rather being Anonymous..i m not here to spill some poetry as Anonymous..Hope some guys get it wat i trying to say

FREE OXYGEN CYLINDER SERVICE

Agar emergency mein patient ko Oxygen Cylinder  ki zaroorat padti hai to Please call our helpline for EMERGENCY OXYGEN CYLINDER CYL...